Speaking the truth... | Town Crier News Nigeria | Whatsapp No: 08027723347, 08072777599,08122784467,09063474539

N152m Oak Homes Property Dispute: Court Admits Offer Letter as Exhibit, Rejects Three Documents

N152m Oak Homes Property Dispute: Court Admits Offer Letter as Exhibit, Rejects Three Documents

 

N152m Oak Homes Property Dispute: Court Admits Offer Letter as Exhibit, Rejects Three Documents

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Written By Dedeigbo Samson Ayodeji

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted By Town Crier News Nigeria

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Published By Fitness Network Communications

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Justice Musa Kakaki of the Federal High Court, Lagos, has admitted as exhibit the February 5, 2024 offer letter tendered in the N152 million disputed property case between United States-based Engineer, Anthony Ugbebor and Lagos property developer, Olukayode Olusanya and his company, Oak Homes Limited.

The court however rejected three other documents sought to be tendered by the prosecution, ruling that they were photocopies whose originals could not be accounted for.

 

The ruling was delivered on Monday following objections raised during proceedings on July 20, 2026, when the prosecution sought to tender the documents through the nominal complainant, Engr. Ugbebor.

Justice Kakaki held that the witness failed to explain the whereabouts of the original copies of the three rejected documents.

On the February 5, 2024 offer letter, the judge overruled the defence objection that Ugbebor was not the maker of the document, and admitted it as exhibit.

After the ruling, Police prosecutor, Chief Superintendent of Police, CSP Monday Omo-Osagie, informed the court of an interim application for virtual hearing for the complainant on health grounds, stating that the defendants had been served.

But counsel to the first defendant, Adeleke Agboola, SAN, challenged Omo-Osagie’s status, claiming information that he had retired from the Police.

He demanded clarification on whether the prosecutor had obtained a fiat from the Inspector-General of Police to continue prosecution.

“The case for today was for ruling and continuation of trial.

The prosecutor should call his witness or close his case,” Agboola argued, describing the application as an attempt to re-litigate an issue already decided by the court.

Similarly, counsel to Oak Homes Limited, Jude Ehiedu, questioned the prosecutor’s authority and described the application as an abuse of court process, arguing that the court had on June 23, 2026 dismissed a similar request for virtual testimony.

Responding, CSP Omo-Osagie insisted he remains a serving police officer until issued a certificate of discharge, and challenged the defence to produce any discharge certificate.

He explained that the new application, dated September 18 and filed September 21, 2026, was distinct from the earlier one.

While the previous application was based on the complainant residing outside Nigeria, the current one borders on his ill health.

Justice Kakaki said the application was not in the court’s file and directed the registry to verify its filing.

The case was stood down.

Upon resumption, Omo-Osagie told the court that registry officials confirmed receipt of the application, signed for by a registrar, and tendered another copy in open court.

“My lord, this is not the first time this will be happening; this is the second time in a series.

I will really like something to be done,” the prosecutor complained.

Moving the motion, Omo-Osagie said it was supported by a 12-paragraph affidavit and written address, urging the court to allow the complainant to testify virtually.

Defence counsels opposed the application.

Benson Nwosu, who held brief for Agboola SAN, argued that the prosecution should appeal the earlier ruling instead of filing a fresh application seeking the same relief.

“The matter can even be adjourned sine die.

It is not compulsory that the nominal complainant must testify.

The prosecution should close its case,” Nwosu submitted.

The judge, after listening to arguments, adjourned the matter till December 3, 2026 for ruling on the application.

At the last hearing on July 20, Engr. Ugbebor had testified how he entered into the transaction in November 2017 after being assured that Oak Homes was a reputable developer capable of delivering a retirement home.

He said he signed the agreement via email and made four payments between November 2017 and December 2020 totalling N152 million, representing 80 percent of the N190 million price for two flats on the second floor of the development.

Describing the sum as his life savings of about $400,000, Ugbebor said: “My income is in dollars.

After payment, the defendant started acting in a suspicious manner, basically taking my patience and simplicity for stupidity.”

He said the project was billed for delivery on February 28, 2019, but stalled, prompting a site inspection on October 11, 2022, before he petitioned the AIG, Zone 2 Command, Lagos, on December 10, 2023.

 


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com
Visit Us On Facebook